• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Our Country Life

From scratch, from the garden, from our Idaho homestead — one skill at a time.

  • Recipes
  • Canning
  • Gardening
  • Animals
  • Country Life
  • Sourdough
  • First Batch — A Beginner’s Guide to Safe & Simple Water Bath Canning

How to Make the Best Tasting Homemade Mayonnaise – 2 Easy Methods

This page may contain affiliate links. Learn More.

March 1, 2024 by Yvonne Gallia Leave a Comment

Jump to Instructions

Making your own mayo is easy with this simple recipe. Give it a try and you will make the best tasting homemade mayonnaise. You only need a few ingredients and a stand or immersion blender. These methods give you a delicious creamy mayo that’s perfect for salads, sandwiches, or dipping sauces.

homemade mayonnaise in jar with lemon next to it

  

 

It is satisfying to know the quality of the ingredients that go into homemade mayo. I have not purchased mayo for years now; why would I when I have chickens laying me farm fresh eggs daily?

Before I owned my own chickens, Best Foods Mayonnaise was in my refrigerator for as long as I can remember.  Since the ladies joined us, I have tried many recipes and finally came up with one to call my own. 

Making your own homemade mayonnaise allows you to add ingredients that make wonderful spreads and dips.  Try adding fresh herbs such as chives, rosemary, basil, dill, cilantro, or any favorite herbs or combination of herbs and spices.   Make your own fry sauce by adding ketchup, mustard, and relish.  Other great variations include adding garlic, Sriracha, or curry; let your imagination go wild!

Best tasting homemade mayonnaise mayonnaise in jar with knife on it.  Lemon and olive oil in the background

If you want to channel Julia Child, make mayonnaise the traditional way with a whisk. Using a blender, food processor, or immersion blender will make quick work of this. I made mayo with each method, but have found my two favorite methods.

Where did this versatile condiment have its beginning?

Mayonnaise is one of the most versatile condiments used in the culinary world, whether it is for a spread on a sandwich, making dressings, or dipping sauces, but do we know the real story behind this jar of creamy goodness? Mayonnaise wasn’t always a deli staple.

It is said that the history of mayonnaise is not very clear. One story goes that it was created on the Spanish island of Menorca during the 18th century. Another is that it was the result of the Battle of Port Mahon that took place in May 1756 between France and England. After the defeat of France, the Duke de Richelieu decided to celebrate with a feast, but there was no olive oil available. He ordered chefs to make a new sauce using egg yolks and instead of oil, they used cream. Thus, a creamy white sauce known as mayonnaise was born.

Most recipes of the 18th century were made with egg yolks, oil, vinegar, and mustard – pretty much the same recipe we use today.

Although there are different versions of stories, one thing is for sure, mayonnaise became popular in the 19th century thanks to a chef, Charles Ranhofer, who invented the famous “dressing” sauce in New York’s legendary Delmonico’s restaurant. From there, it spread across America and the world, becoming a kitchen staple.

A little-known fact about mayonnaise is that it played an essential role in the rise of fast food. In the 1920s, mayonnaise companies began funding cooking schools, providing recipes and courses on how to make salads and sandwiches with mayonnaise, and urging homemakers to put mayonnaise in everything. The tactic worked, and soon, mayonnaise was everywhere, from burgers to hotdogs to salads, and it continues to be a popular choice for condiments today.

How to Make the Best Tasting Homemade Mayonnaise

Let’s go over the ingredients for this best tasting homemade mayonnaise recipe.

My mayonnaise recipe is made from our farm fresh eggs, extra light olive oil, lemon juice, white vinegar, dry mustard, a dash of Cayenne pepper, salt, and a touch of sugar, which Is optional.

Eggs

It is important that the eggs are at room temperature. Since this recipe has a raw egg, the USDA recommends you use pasteurized eggs. I am comfortable with the handling of my farm fresh eggs. I use the very freshest ones, laid that day, and wash the eggs before cracking them open to make sure there is no bacteria contamination. Please read my article on How to Handle Farm Fresh Eggs Like a Pro.

Extra Light Olive Oil

Of course, you can substitute the oil for vegetable, canola, or avocado oil. The only one that I would not recommend is extra virgin olive oil; it tends to give the mayonnaise a fishy taste.

Lemon Juice

Fresh lemon juice is best, but I always have lemon juice concentrate on hand for canning. So, if I don’t have fresh lemon on hand, I substitute with lemon juice concentrate.

White Vinegar

You can substitute the white vinegar with apple cider or rice vinegar for a milder taste. I use white vinegar because it produces a finished mayonnaise closest to my copycat version of Best Foods Mayonnaise.

Dry Mustard

If you do not have dry mustard, then you could substitute with Dijon mustard.

Dash of Cayenne Pepper

The dash of Cayenne Pepper does not make the mayonnaise spicy; it just rounds out the flavor nicely.

Salt

I use medium coarse sea salt or kosher salt. If you substitute with table salt, I would cut the amount back to 3/4 teaspoon since the grain size of table salt is smaller than the medium course sea salt or kosher salt I use.

Sugar (Optional)

Sugar is definitely optional, but again this small amount gives me the closest version to Best Food Mayonnaise.

Method 1 – My Simple Blender Trick

My blender trick helps me consistently make tasty mayonnaise every time.

The simple trick that makes my blender version so easy is that I drilled a 1/8″ hole in my blender lid plug.   Your blender plug must be made out of plastic for this to work.  As you can see in the picture, it takes all the guesswork out of measuring the oil (my plug holds exactly 1/4 cup of oil)  and adds the oil at the perfect slow stream to emulsify the mixture.

Blender lid pug hole
Egg yolk into the blender
Oil streamed into blender thru blender lid plug

My simple blender trick makes this the best tasting homemade mayonnaise recipe, not only easy but thick and creamy.

Method 2 – Super Easy Immersion Blender Version

The nice thing about this version is that you make the mayonnaise in the storage container. This makes cleanup fast since you are only having to clean the immersion blender.

Even though this method is super easy, I have found that my blender version makes a thicker finished mayonnaise which I usually prefer.

In this version, you will need only the immersion blender and a 16-ounce, wide-mouth canning jar.

After you place the eggs in first, then the oil, and finally the remaining ingredients; it is important that you place the immersion blender into the bottom of the jar before starting the blender. After starting the immersion blender and it begins to emulsify the ingredients, move the immersion blender stick up very slowly. Once the ingredients have blended, then the stick blender can be moved up and down.

As I mentioned above, this version is not quite as thick as my blender version, but it turns out to be a great-tasting mayonnaise.

Our Country life jar of Best tasting homemade mayonnaise with spoon in it.  Immersion blender in background

The recipe with both versions.

You may enjoy these blog posts

farm fresh eggs with text that reads how to handle your farm fresh eggs like a pro
Egg float test with a basket of eggs
Print Recipe
mayonnaise in jar with lemon on the side

How to Make the Best Tasting Homemade Mayonnaise – 2 Easy Methods

No ratings yet
Print Pin Recipe
Made This Recipe?Enjoyed this recipe? I’d love it if you leave a star rating!

Ingredients
  

  • 1 Whole Egg – room temperature
  • 1 Egg Yolk – room temperature
  • 1 Cup Extra Light Olive Oil
  • 1 ½ Tablespoons Lemon Juice
  • 1 Tablespoon White Vinegar
  • 1 Teaspoon Dry Mustard
  • ½ Teaspoon Sea or Kosher Salt
  • ½ Teaspoon Sugar Optional
  • Dash Cayenne Pepper

Instructions
 

Stand Blender Version

  • Add all ingredients except the extra light olive oil into the blender.
  • Blend on low for a few seconds before adding oil.
  • If you have a small hole in the blender lid plug, place the plug upside down and with the blender switched to high, pour oil into the cap.
    The mayonaisse will become very thick and you may need to turn the speed down for the last 1/4 cup.
    oil added to blender

Immersion Blender Version

  • Place eggs in jar first and then add oil and remaining ingredients.
  • Insert the stick blender into the jar all the way to the bottom before running it. Once you have started the immersion blender, blend for a few seconds before moving the blender stick up the jar slowly. Once the ingredients have combined, then you can move the blender stick up and down for a few more seconds.
    Mayonnaise blended in jar with immersion blender
Tried this recipe?Let us know how it was!

That is all there is to it, so easy and so delicious!

jar of homemade mayonnaise

Once you make your own mayo at home, you’ll never want to go back to store-bought. It’s easy, it’s delicious, and it’s customizable to your preferences. Plus, you can make it with only a few ingredients that you probably already have in your pantry. So why not give it a try? I promise you won’t be disappointed.

Give both methods a try, and let me know if you agree that this is the best tasting homemade mayonnaise!

Yvonne♥
Thanks for visiting my blog - please leave comment below and rate my recipe
Yvonne Gallia

Hi, I’m Yvonne — the voice behind Our Country Life. I share from-scratch recipes, garden know-how, and simple living inspiration rooted in real farmhouse life. Thanks for being here ❤️

 

Filed Under: All Blog Posts, Recipes Tagged With: Dips and Sauces, Food Hacks, Homesteading, Sauce Recipes

Previous Post: « Starting Seeds Indoors – An Easy Guide For Success
Next Post: White Lady Cocktail Recipe – A Beautiful Classic Cocktail »

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Search

Follow Us!

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
Yvonne from our country life

Hi, I am Yvonne, the blogger of Our Country Life.

I am dedicated to sharing my passions:

  • Home cooking
  • Gardening
  • Raising animals
  • Country Living

Together, let’s embrace the charm of old-fashioned living. You’ll be amazed at how fulfilling it can be!

Learn more about Our Country Life here!

  • About Me
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy and Disclosures
  • Home – Our Country Life
  • Subscriber Printable Library

Copyright © 2026 · Niche Theme

Rate This Recipe

Your vote:




Tried this recipe? Leave a quick rating and review — it helps other readers and means so much!

A rating is required
A name is required
An email is required